Those of you excited about the idea of “free” health care would do well to remember that government programs tend to promote mediocrity and indifference, not hope and transcendence. Unless of course, you count death as transcendence.
PHILADELPHIA – Four social workers were among nine people charged Thursday in the death of a disabled 14-year-old girl who authorities say wasted away from neglect before dying at 42 pounds.
Danieal Kelly’s mother was charged with murder; counts against other defendants range from involuntary manslaughter to perjury. District Attorney Lynne Abraham said any of the nine could have foreseen the horrific fate of Danieal, whose emaciated body was found in her mother’s squalid house covered with bone-deep, maggot-infested bedsores in August 2006.
Abraham had scathing words for the city’s Department of Human Services, calling its handling of the case “callous, indifferent, unconscionable” — and all too familiar.
Starving to death is a horrible way to go. I realize that children in state care do not all starve to death. However, the common theme among those in state care seems to be mediocrity at best and callous indifference and worse seem to be omnipresent. My wife is the product of the state foster care system of New York and was abused by her foster parents.
Danieal had the misfortune to be born to a mother unfit to care for her, or so indifferent and depraved that she didn’t have enough humanity in her to give a shit.
A 258-page grand jury report recommending the charges said not only that Andrea Kelly refused to get her daughter food, water and medical treatment, but that she repeatedly prevented one of her other children from calling an ambulance “for his obviously dying sister.”
A listing for Andrea Kelly’s attorney, Vincent Giusini, rang unanswered Thursday. It was not immediately clear if Daniel Kelly, 37, of Darby, had an attorney; two phone numbers listed in his name were disconnected.
Two employees of MultiEthnic Behavioral Health, a now-defunct company that DHS hired to provide social services to Danieal, falsified documents to cover up the fact they rarely, if ever, checked on her, the grand jury said.
Julius Murray and Mickal Kamuvaka were charged with involuntary manslaughter and tampering with public records.
Under Obamacare, we should expect more stories like this one. Think of all the horror stories you’ve read recently in relation to the Veteran’s Administration – the giant bureaucracy entrusted with caring for our wounded troops. Our wounded troops receive mediocre care precisely because the Veteran’s Administration is a giant state run monopoly. While there are undoubtedly many humane and motivated caregivers within the organization there is no motivation to excel at providing wounded troops with the care they need because there is no competition. You get whoever you get. The level of care is decided not by common sense and your need. It is decided by bureaucrats with rule books.
State run child care services follow the exact same bureaucratic structure, albeit on a smaller scale. And children die because of the arbitrary nature of the organization.
DHS social worker Dana Poindexter was charged with child endangerment for what the grand jury said were his “less than meager” efforts to look into several reports over three years that Danieal, who had cerebral palsy, was not receiving medical care, social services or schooling.
“He did not complete a single investigation or risk assessment,” the report said. “Indeed, his file on the family was buried at the bottom of a filing-cabinet-sized box, beneath food wrappers and unopened envelopes relating to other children’s cases.”
In a bureaucracy, it is hard to fire an employee. In a bureaucracy, you are promoted primarily based on how long you hang around, not on merit. In a bureaucracy, problem employees are shuffled around into dark corners where they can thrive like a fungus, causing problems for untold numbers of citizens with little fear of repercussions. Only blatant and horrible outcomes will draw enough attention to the nature of their existence for anything to be done.
Unfortunately, the typical reaction is to put in place more bureaucrats and more arbitrary rules. This costs money. Arbitrary rules rob the people forced to follow them of creativity, motivation and hope. The problem self-perpetuates until almost everything coming out of the giant bureaucracy is completely mediocre and homogenous. More little girls are burned with cigarettes, starved to death, and abused in myriad ways.
People with a conscience complain and vote for more government. Eventually, the system collapses under the weight of its own inefficiency. In the mean time, expect more of this:
Also charged were Andrea Miles, Marie Moses and Diamond Brantley, all of Philadelphia, who were friends with Andrea Kelly. The report accuses them of perjury for telling grand jurors that Danieal had been fine on Aug. 3, 2006, the day before her festering corpse was taken from the house.
It was not immediately clear if they had attorneys. A message left for Moses was not immediately returned; phone numbers could not found for Miles and Brantley.
The report should “outrage the entire Philadelphia community” and bring about “earth-shattering, cataclysmic changes” at the Department of Human Services, Abraham said.
Abraham said that although at least 55 children have died under the agency’s watch, it has given only “lip service to halfhearted corrective action.
Monopolies by government agencies will never solve our social ills. They only make them worse in the long run. Remember Danieal when you are voting for more government.